Tease and Tangle Logotype
Cover image for blog category Relationships Communication

The Pitfalls of Keeping Score in Relationships

Stop keeping score and start playing on the same team

profile picture of Mark
· 4 min read
Turned off football stadium scoreboard

Sharing your life with someone can be both a fulfilling and challenging experience. Caring for someone else while being supported yourself is in many ways a delicate balancing act. At times, it may feel like all of the sandbags are piled onto your side of the scale. It's tempting to keep a mental tally of all your sacrifices and all of their misdeeds. This act of "keeping score" may seem justified or even necessary, after all, you're clearly the one putting in all the effort, right? This internal echo chamber may become a hidden poison that slowly erodes the foundation of any relationship. In this post, we'll delve into why keeping score is unhealthy and explore ways to foster a more positive and fulfilling connection with your partner.

Erosion of Trust

At the heart of every thriving relationship lies trust. Keeping score introduces an element of competition, turning the partnership into a contest rather than a collaboration. When partners start tallying up each other's perceived wrongs or slights, trust begins to erode. This erosion, if left unchecked, can breed resentment and create an emotional chasm between partners.

Unrealistic Expectations

When you engage in a constant comparison and scorekeeping, you unknowingly set the stage for disappointment. Your perspective will be biased, inflating your own actions as grand gestures with unrealistic expectations to be matched. It's unlikely your partner will meet these exceptionally high standards all the time. Inevitably, people will have moments of imperfection, make mistakes, or have days when they may not be able to contribute as much as they normally would. These moments are not indicative of a lack of love or commitment. When you fail to account for these fluctuations and instead cling to rigid expectations, it becomes a breeding ground for frustration and dissatisfaction. It's important to remember that a healthy relationship thrives on understanding, forgiveness, and a willingness to navigate life's challenges together rather than dwelling on perceived shortcomings.

Diminished Emotional Intimacy

Intimacy thrives in an environment of vulnerability and open communication. When partners start tallying wrongs or perceived injustices, they often build emotional walls to protect themselves. This wall hinders the free flow of emotions, making it difficult for both partners to express their true feelings and needs. In the long run, this lack of emotional intimacy can lead to a disconnection that is hard to repair.

Focus on Negativity

Keeping score tends to magnify the negative aspects of the relationship while overshadowing the positive. Instead of appreciating the good times, partners find themselves fixated on past grievances, fostering a pessimistic outlook. This negativity can become a self-fulfilling prophecy, as constantly dwelling on the negative aspects of the relationship can attract more negativity.

Stifling Personal Growth

In a healthy relationship, both partners should encourage and support each other's personal growth. However, keeping score can stifle individual development, as partners may be hesitant to take risks or pursue personal goals for fear of being judged or criticized. This hindrance to personal growth can lead to stagnation and resentment over time.

Healthier Options

To foster a healthy and thriving connection, it's crucial to let go of the need to tally every perceived wrong. Instead, focus on open communication, empathy, and the cultivation of a positive and supportive environment. Talk about the things that are bothering you. Express your gratitude for the sacrifices your partner makes. It might seem cliché, but starting conversations with "I feel like my contributions are overlooked when...", or "I really appreciate it when you...". By doing so, you create a relationship that is built on trust, understanding, and the shared goal of growing together. After all, love is not a game to be won; it's a journey to be experienced and enjoyed together. Read more about healthier options in our article on Nurturing Healthy Connections: What to Do Instead of Keeping Score in Relationships.